Was It Really a Punch to the Gut That Took Harry Houdini Out?

According to legend, the magician, illusionist, and master escape artist Harry Houdini died on Halloween in 1926. As the story goes, an overeager fan literally punched him in the gut, causing his appendix to rupture. But it might not be the case. Are these two events – his death and the literally gut-wrenching event – really linked?

Harry Houdini standing in chains / A poster advertising an appearance by Houdini circa 1904 / Harry Houdini standing with shakles on in front of a large body of water

Photo by Everett Collection, Shutterstock / Granger, Shutterstock / Courtesy Everett Collection, Shutterstock

Houdini defied the impossible throughout his mystifying career, which turned him into a household name that still gets mentioned even today. He was known for swallowing needles to pulling himself out of a dead whale. His famous “Chinese Water Torture Cell” stunt dazzled millions. So how could it be that something as “minor” as a punch to the gut ended it all? And the fact that he died on Halloween only made the circumstances surrounding his death even more eerie and hard to believe. In fact, the mystery and speculation have fascinated people ever since.

He Dazzled America with His Stunts

For more than 30 years, Harry Houdini dazzled his audiences with brave (albeit insane) stunts and superhuman endurance. The master escape artist would do things like jump off bridges wearing handcuffs and leg irons. He would slither out of sealed, oversized milk cans (of all things) filled with water, and he escaped from a “Chinese Water Torture Cell” after being submerged and suspended upside down by his ankles.

A younger Harry Houdini / Harry Houdini in handcuffs before one of his escapes

Photo by Granger / Shutterstock (left and right)

The audience, hearts in their mouths, would watch as Houdini made his getaways. While his stunts usually involved trickery and sleight-of-hand, they were also loaded with real life-threatening risk. In 1915, for instance, Houdini almost suffocated during a stunt which had him shackled and buried under six feet of dirt.

A State of Awe and Confusion

The wild and incredible Houdini made a successful career out of surviving the impossible, which only makes the scenario of his death all the more mysterious. After decades of death-defying tricks, the 52-year-old performed for a packed house in Detroit on October 24, 1926. But after the show, he was rushed to the hospital with an apparent case of appendicitis.

Houdini with handcuffs on

Photo by Famous Players / Lasky / Kobal / Shutterstock

He died a week later, on Halloween, leaving his admirers in a state of confusion and awe. His obituary in The New York Times left readers in shock at the sudden passing of a man “who so often had seemed to thousands to be cheating the very jaws of death.”

Ehrich, the Prince of the Air

Harry Houdini was born in Budapest, Hungary, on March 24, 1874 as Erik Weisz, one of seven children. He and his family immigrated to the United States in 1878, on the S.S. Fresia. Once in the country, the Jewish family changed their name to the German spelling Weiss, and Erik then became Ehrich.

A photograph of Harry Houdini when he was still known as Ehrich Weiss in 1890

Ehrich Weiss (later Houdini) circa 1890 wearing medals from his performance with the track team. Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

They lived in Appleton, Wisconsin, on Appleton Street – an area now known as Houdini Square. By 1882, the family moved to Milwaukee and fell into grim poverty. In 1887, Ehrich and his father, a rabbi, moved to New York City to live in a boarding house on East 79th Street. Once they found permanent housing, the rest of the family joined. As a child, Ehrich was forced to take several jobs. He made his public debut as a 9-year-old trapeze artist. He called himself “Ehrich, the Prince of the Air.”

Becoming Harry Houdini, the “Handcuff King”

He started his career in stunts at an early age. His start as a trapeze artist at age nine was just the beginning. By 1891, at the age of 17, he launched a Vaudeville career in magic. It was then that he changed his name to Harry Houdini – to honor the famous French magician, Jean Eugène Robert-Houdin.

Harry Houdini in a jail cell with balls and chains attached to him

Photo by Moviestore Collection / Shutterstock

As Houdini, he became known as the “handcuff king” who marveled his audiences around the world with his daring escapes. His most famous escape – the water torture cell in 1913 – involved having only two minutes to escape. Obviously, he pulled it off, to the amusement and relief of his audiences.

A Career Not Suited for the Faint of Heart

Houdini was theatrical and had charisma. His rise coincided with a growing revolution of media in the early 20th century. It didn’t take long for him to soar to super-stardom. From 1907 and throughout the 1910s, Houdini was very successful in the US. He escaped from jails, chains, ropes, handcuffs and straitjackets – all while typically hanging from a rope in front of street audiences.

Houdini hanging midair over a subway excavation wearing a straightjacket in New York City / Houdini hanging in the same spot with the jacket off

Photo by Granger / Shutterstock (left and right)

The possibility of both failure and even death kept his audiences hypnotized. He also wrote a collection of articles on the history of magic, which he published in 1908. Throughout his career, some of Houdini’s escapes became particularly notable. Let’s go through the most notorious ones…

1904: The Mirror Challenge

In 1904, The London Daily Mirror newspaper challenged Houdini to escape from special handcuffs that the Mirror claimed took Nathaniel Hart (a locksmith) five years to make. 4,000 people, including over 100 journalists, watched as the escape attempt dragged on for more than an hour, with Houdini emerging from his “ghost house” (a small screen that concealed his methods) several times.

Harry Houdini trying to escape from chains and handcuffs

Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

56 minutes after Houdini used a pen-knife to cut his coat off from his body – with his teeth – his wife Bess came on stage and gave him a kiss. (Many believed that she had the key to unlock the special handcuffs in her mouth, but the fact that the key was six inches makes that theory a little less likely.)

The Most Difficult of His Career

After 70 minutes, Houdini emerged free of the handcuffs. As he was being patted on the shoulders and cheered by the crowd, the escape artist broke down and wept. He later claimed that it was the most difficult escape of his career. Many modern biographers found evidence (mostly in the custom design of the handcuffs) that the Mirror challenge might have been arranged by Houdini himself.

Houdini in a boat with handcuffs and chains on him

Source: Shutterstock

They claim that his long struggle to escape was just a matter of showmanship. A full-sized design of those handcuffs as well as a replica of the key is on display at The Houdini Museum in Scranton, Pennsylvania. The set of cuffs is said to be one of only six in the world.

1908: The Milk Can Escape

In 1908, Houdini brought his own original act, the Milk Can Escape, to the table. Houdini was handcuffed and locked inside an oversized milk can that was filled with water, and he made his escape behind a curtain. As part of the show, Houdini invited the members of his audience to hold their breath along with him for the time he was inside the can.

Houdini being closed in a mlik can filled with water circa 1908

Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

The posters leading up to the stunt read “Failure Means a Drowning Death.” Houdini then modified the act by locking the milk inside a wooden chest, chained or padlocked shut. This act was a regular part of his act for just four years, but it became one of the ones most associated with him.

1912: The Chinese Water Torture Cell

Around 1912, after seeing the large number of Houdini imitators, Houdini decided to replace his milk can act with the water torture cell. His feet were locked in stocks, and he was lowered upside down into a tank filled with water. The glass walls of the cell meant audiences could clearly see him, but a curtain concealed his escape. In the earliest version of the act, a metal cage was lowered in, and Houdini was enclosed inside it.

Houdini hanging by his feet above a water cell

Houdinis water torture cell escape. Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

But the cage prevented him from turning. He used the original cell, built in England, in his first performance of the stunt, as part of a one-act play called “Houdini Upside Down.” It was for the sole purpose of copywriting the effect, giving him grounds to sue imitators – which he did. The escape is known as “The Chinese Water Torture Cell,” but Houdini always called it The Upside Down or USD. He performed the act until his death.

1912: The Overboard Box Escape

His next famous stunt involved being inside a nailed and roped packing crate that was lowered into water. The first time he performed it was in New York’s East River on July 7, 1912. Police restricted him from using one of the city’s piers, so he used a tugboat and even invited the press to come on board.

Houdini showing everyone that his handcuffs are on while standing at the side of a boat in the the New York Harbor / Houdini inside of a large box being lowered into the New York Harbor

Houdini’s overboard box escape. Photo by Granger / Shutterstock (left and right)

Houdini was then locked in handcuffs and leg-irons and entered the crate that was roped and weighed down with 200 lbs. of lead. The crate was lowered into the water. He escaped within 57 seconds. After the crate was pulled to the surface, people saw that everything was still intact. Houdini performed this act many times.

1915: The Suspended Straitjacket Escape

Houdini strapped himself into a regulation straitjacket and was suspended by his ankles from a tall building or a crane. He then made his escape in full view of the crowd. Many times, Houdini attracted tens of thousands of onlookers, bringing the city traffic to a halt. In New York City, he performed this escape from a crane that was being used to build the subway.

Houdini suspended from an NY skyscraper while wearing a straightjacket

Houdini performing a suspended straightjacket escape from the top of a New York Skyscraper. Photo by Historia / Shutterstock

From the time he was hoisted up in the air to when the jacket was completely off, the escape took him two minutes and 37 seconds. One time, after being injured against a building wall due to high winds, Houdini started performing the act with a visible safety wire around his ankle. That way, he could be pulled away if necessary.

1915: The Buried Alive Stunt

Houdini performed at least three versions of this stunt during his career. The first was time was in Santa Ana, California, in 1915. And it almost cost him his life. He was buried, with no casket, in a pit of earth six feet under. During that first performance, he got exhausted and panicked. He tried to dig his way to the surface and call for help.

Harry Houdini lying on the floor covered in ropes with one hand in the air

Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

As his hand broke the surface, he went unconscious and had to be pulled out by his assistants. He later wrote in his diary that the entire stunt was “very dangerous” and that “the weight of the earth is killing.” That was his first version of the notorious stunt. He learned what to do next time…

No Supernatural Powers Over Here

Houdini’s second version of the buried alive act was a sort of endurance test. It was designed to expose the mystical Egyptian performer of the time, Rahman Bey, who claimed to use “supernatural powers” to stay inside a sealed casket for an hour (more on his hatred of Spiritualism soon). On August 5, 1926, months before his death, Houdini remained in a sealed casket, submerged in a swimming pool at New York’s Hotel Shelton for 90 minutes.

Harry Houdini waving as he is placed in a casket about to be put into a pool of water

Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

His final buried alive performance was on a much more elaborate stage that occurred during a full evening show. He escaped after being strapped in a straitjacket, sealed in a coffin, and buried in a large tank of sand. The stunt was meant to be the feature escape of his upcoming 1927 season. But, of course, he died before that ever happened.

Rather ironically, the bronze casket he created for the buried alive act was used to transport his body from Detroit to New York after his death.

At the Top of His Game…Until 1926

By 1926, at age 52, Houdini was at the top of his game. He was touring the country in the beginning of the year, performing escapes and enjoying fame. But his tour that fall was the beginning of the end. On October 11, Houdini ended up breaking his ankle while performing the water torture cell escape in Albany, New York.

Harry Houdini standing with shakles on in front of a large body of water

Photo by Courtesy Everett Collection / Shutterstock

Against his doctor’s orders, he pushed through the next several appearances. He then headed to Montreal, Canada. There, after a lecture concerning “spirit fraud,” Houdini schmoozed with the students and faculty. Among them was Samuel J. “Smiley” Smilovitch, who sketched the famous magician. Houdini loved the drawing so much that he invited Smiley to do a proper portrait on October 22.

The Question That Sparked His Final Stunt

Smiley came to visit Houdini at his dressing room with a friend, Jack Price, and a student named Jocelyn Gordon Whitehead. As Smiley sketched Houdini, Whitehead chatted with Houdini. After talking about Houdini’s physical strength, Whitehead asked him if it was true that he could endure even the strongest punch to the stomach.

Harry Houdini surrounded by people handcuffed and legs shakled next to a body of water

Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

Jack Price recalled the following in the book The Life and Many Deaths of Harry Houdini: “Houdini remarked rather unenthusiastically that his stomach could resist much.” He described how Whitehead then went ahead and gave Houdini some “very hammer-like blows below the belt, first securing Houdini’s permission to strike him.” You see, Houdini was reclining on a couch at the time.

Too Many Punches to the Gut

That day, on October 22, during what was supposed to be a time for his professional portrait, Whitehead struck Houdini at least four times, until Houdini motioned for him to stop mid-punch. According to Price, Houdini “looked as though he was in extreme pain and winced as each blow was struck.” This was a man who claimed that he could “resist much.”

Houdini being held back while Jack Dempsey has his arm back ready to punch him in the gut

Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

According to Houdini, he didn’t think Whitehead would strike him so suddenly – otherwise he would have been better prepared for it. By that evening, Houdini was suffering – his stomach was in tremendous pain. The next evening, he left Montreal via overnight train to Detroit, Michigan. He asked a doctor to have a look at him.

“I’ll Do This Show If It’s My Last”

The doctor ultimately diagnosed Houdini with acute appendicitis, telling him to go immediately to the hospital. But, he had a show that night in Detroit, at the Garrick Theater, with $15,000 worth of tickets already sold. Houdini reportedly said: “I’ll do this show if it’s my last.” And so, he carried on with the show, that night on October 24, despite a temperature of 104°F.

Harry Houdini standing around people

Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

Between the first and second acts, he was given ice packs to cool down. Some reports say that he passed out during the performance. By the time the third act began, he had called off the show. Yet, he still refused to go to the hospital. That is, until his wife forced him to.

Rushed to the Hospital on October 25

A physician from the hotel was then called, followed by his personal doctor, who at 3 a.m. finally convinced him to go to Grace Hospital. On the afternoon of October 25, surgeons removed Houdini’s appendix. But because he delayed treatment for so long, his appendix had already ruptured and the lining of his stomach was inflamed with what is called peritonitis.

Harry Houdini performing magic with his rabbit in the hospital for sick children

Houdini performing magic with his rabbit for hospitalized children. Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

Today, such a case would simply require a round of antibiotics. But this was 1926, and antibiotics wouldn’t be discovered for three more years. And so, the infection spread throughout Houdini’s body. His bowels became paralyzed and more surgery was needed. He ended up receiving two operations.

It Was Too Late

During one of the operations, he was injected with an experimental anti-streptococcal serum. At first, it seemed to help him recover somewhat, but he relapsed quickly, overcome by sepsis. At 1:26 p.m. on October 31, 1926, Houdini died in his wife’s arms. His last words were reportedly: “I’m getting tired and I can’t fight anymore.”

Houdini hanging from a ledge of a cliff

Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

The question that surrounds Houdini’s death is whether or not there was a causal link between Whitehead’s punches to his ruptured organ. Back in 1926, such blows to the abdomen were believed to cause a ruptured appendix. However, these days, the medical community debates such a link. It’s possible that the uppercuts led to the appendicitis, but it’s also very possible that these two events just happened to coincide. Remember, as your math teacher always said, “Correlation does not infer causation.”

Sucker Punch + Stomach = Death?

Houdini’s official cause of death was peritonitis caused by a ruptured appendix. But it’s said that such a case of “traumatic appendicitis” is extremely rare — one study found a few dozen instances over a 20-year period. But, again, it was 1926, and this diagnosis was widely accepted. Houdini’s life insurance company, by the way, had to pay his wife double coverage for her husband’s accidental death.

Harry Houdini in front of a senate committee holding up two rectangular items

Houdini appearing before a Senate committee to expose fake spiritualists. Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

Houdini was buried in Queens on November 4, 1926, but theories about his unusual death have persisted ever since. Many of them focus on the magician’s hatred of Spiritualism, a pseudo-religion that claimed it was possible to communicate with the deceased through séances and mediums. Houdini, you see, was a born skeptic.

But the World Needed It

Spiritualism reached its peak popularity back in the 1920s. To give you a bit of perspective, World War I had just ended, killing 16 million people across the world. Then, the Spanish flu of 1918 wiped out 50 million more. The globe was traumatized by death. Thus, a religious movement that professed to keep the deceased somewhat alive was surely attractive.

Harry Houdini handing another man a handful of bonds

Harry Houdini paying William McMorris to challenge Margery Chandon’s claim as a spiritual medium December 1924. Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

With the movement came a flood of “mediums,” or people who turned into celebrities for their supposed ability to communicate with the dead. They used all sorts of tricks to fool people into thinking they had these supernatural abilities. Houdini, who used real laws of physics, couldn’t stand it.

Debunking the Great Margery

In his most famous anti-Spiritualism debunking, Houdini showed up to two séances in 1924 held by Boston medium Mina Crandon, known as “Margery.” She claimed to be able to raise the voice of her dead brother Walter. She was up for a $2,500 prize, but she had to prove her spiritual powers to a six-person committee of respected scientists from Harvard, MIT, and other educational institutions.

Mina Crandon posing for a portrait / Harry Houdini posing for a portrait

Photo by Historia, Shutterstock / Granger, Shutterstock

Houdini, however, was intent on keeping her from winning that prize money. So, he went to her séances in the summer of 1924, and, as a witness, he was able to deduce how she performed her tricks. He saw how she would use a mix of distractions and contraptions.

An Eerie Prediction Turned Reality

Houdini recorded his findings in a pamphlet, adding drawings of how he thought her tricks worked. He even performed them for his own audiences – a play of sorts that was met with much laughter. As for Crandon’s supporters, they weren’t pleased. In August of 1926, Walter – speaking from the beyond – claimed that “Houdini will be gone by Halloween.”

Harry Houdini lying in a bed tied up with onlookers gathered around

Houdini performing a trick in a cot. Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

That, my friends, turned out to be the case. To the spiritualists, Walter’s prediction of Houdini’s death was their proof that their religion is legitimate. To others, the skeptics, it only fueled a conspiracy theory that the spiritualists were to blame for the magician’s death — that he was actually poisoned, and that Whitehead was in on it…

A Hatred for Spiritualism

Houdini spent much of the 1920s trying to debunk the Spiritualists’ claims, exposing the psychics as frauds. This career-long crusade cost him several million dollars’ worth of lawsuits as well as his fair share of enemies. Up until the day he died, he showed no signs of letting up. In fact, a few months prior to his death, he testified in front of Congress to support a bill that would outlaw fortune-telling in Washington, DC.

Harry Houdini with a fake spirit medium

Harry Houdini with Ira Davenport, who later was discovered to be a fake medium. Photo by Historia / Shutterstock

So, is it possible that Houdini’s meddling in this mysterious world of Spiritualism could have gotten him killed? In their 2006 biography, The Secret Life of Houdini, authors William Kalush and Larry Sloman suggest that his death might have actually been a carefully planned assassination by those in the Spiritualist community.

Could It Be?

“If one were to suspect Houdini a victim of foul play,” the book reads, “then the section of organized crime that was composed of fraudulent spirit mediums must be considered likely suspects.” The authors argue that members of the Spiritualist community had a history of poisoning their enemies. According to Kalush and Sloman, no autopsy was ever performed on Houdini to confirm that his death was indeed caused by appendicitis.

Houdini diving into a pool with chains on

Houdini performing a trick. Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

They also added that if someone really wanted to poison the magician, it wouldn’t have been very difficult. In the 2005 book The Man Who Killed Houdini, writer Don Bell proposed a theory: that Whitehead might have been in cahoots with the Spiritualists. Some of them even threatened to kill Houdini or beat him up.

The Most Pressing Question

Bell ultimately concluded that there just wasn’t enough evidence to prove that Whitehead was involved in a criminal plot. But others argued that he was an “enemy agent” who stalked Houdini during his time in Montreal. The true cause of Houdini’s death might never be truly known, but, for most scholars, the most pressing question is whether his ruptured appendix was a result of the stomach blows he received a few days earlier.

Houdini with his wife, Bell Weiss.

Houdini and his wife. Photo by Historia / Shutterstock

Such a case is indeed possible, but most will tell you that it’s more likely that Whitehead’s punches caused Houdini to ignore his already existing case of appendicitis. By the time he finally sought out medical treatment, it was already too late – at least according to this theory.

Getting a Bit Wild

If you want to get a little bit wild, you can indulge yourself in the possibility of the most sought after source of information about Houdini’s death: Houdini himself. The magician had promised his wife that once he passed on, he would try to contact her from beyond the grave. Bess actually held an annual “Houdini séance” for 10 years before finally giving up in 1936.

Houdini’s wife sitting in a char holding peoples hands with her business manager sitting next to her holding handcuffs

Mrs. Bess Houdini and others during a séance in 1936 in effort to contact the spirit of Houdini. Photo by Everett Collection / Shutterstock

In her tenth and last attempt to contact her late husband, Bess conducted a séance in Los Angeles. She stood with Dr. Edward Saint, who held a pair of handcuffs. Houdini had been the only one who knew the combination to unlock them. Houdini never “showed up” spiritually.

It’s a Sham

Fans and even fellow magicians have since made the annual séance a Halloween tradition. “They usually form a circle, hold hands and say they are friends of Houdini’s,” said an amateur magician who attended a séance in 1940s in New York City. “They ask for some sign that he can hear them. Then they wait five minutes or half an hour and nothing happens.”

Magicians conducting a séance in attempt to contact the spirit of Harry Houdini with his handcuffs, a photograph, and a book placed on a chair in the center of their circle

Magicians conducting a séance in attempt to contact the spirit of Harry Houdini. Photo by Granger / Shutterstock

So far, Houdini has “refused” to speak. At the end of the day, it only proves what he was trying to prove all along – that you can’t communicate with the dead. Houdini had a bone to pick with those who claimed otherwise. In his eyes, it was all a sham.

A Freemason in Harlem

And now for some random facts…

Did you know that Houdini became an active Freemason? He also lived for many years in New York City. In 1904, he bought a townhouse on 278 West 113th Street in Harlem. It cost him $25,000 for the five-story, 6,008-square-foot house. He lived there with Bess and various other relatives until his last days. In March 2018, that very home was purchased for $3.6 million.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Harry Houdini standing outside in suits and top hats

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Harry Houdini. Photo by Historia / Shutterstock

A plaque was placed on the building which reads: “The magician lived here from 1904 to 1926 collecting illusions, theatrical memorabilia, and books on psychic phenomena and magic.”

Fun fact: In 1918, the magician registered for selective service as Harry Handcuff Houdini.

After Houdini Came Theodore

Houdini’s brother, Theodore Hardeen, was also a magician. He returned to performing after his brother’s death, inheriting Houdini’s effects and props. In Houdini’s will, it was stipulated that all his effects be “burned and destroyed” after Hardeen’s death. Hardeen later sold most of the collection to a magician and Houdini enthusiast named Sidney Hollis Radner in the 1940s.

Theodore Hardeen in a straightjacket with a back and front view

Photo by Historia / Shutterstock

Included in the collection was the water torture cell. Radner then chose certain pieces to be displayed at The Houdini Magical Hall of Fame in Niagara Falls. But in 1995, a fire destroyed the museum. The metal frame of the water torture cell remained, though, and it was restored by illusion builder John Gaughan.

Houdini, the Movie Star

In 1918, Houdini signed a contract to star in a 15-part series called The Master Mystery. He was later signed by Famous Players-Lasky Corporation/Paramount Pictures. With them, Houdini made two pictures, The Grim Game (1919) and Terror Island (1920). While filming the movies in Los Angeles, Houdini rented a house in Laurel Canyon.

Harry Houdini on the wings of an old airplane with the wind blowing in his face from the film The Grim Game

Film still from The Grim Game 1919. Photo by Famous Players / Lasky / Kobal / Shutterstock

After his two-picture stint in Hollywood, he went back to New York and started his own production company, Houdini Picture Corporation. He produced and starred in two movies, The Man from Beyond (1921) and Haldane of the Secret Service (1923). That’s when Theodore Hardeen left his career as a magician to run the company (only returning to magic after Houdini died).

Design and Code by elevate